Some initial results and reflections on the blended course

The students in my group have now gone off into school placements for a couple of months, but before going, we captured some of their ideas and thoughts about the course they have been following. Two immediate ideas have become apparent in their views:

1. They enjoyed keeping the blogs on geographical concepts, and in several interviews carried out with students, they commented on the essentially liminal nature of the exercise. They saw the blogs as being a positive medium for playing around with ideas and developing a deeper understanding which not only allowed them to feel more confident in their own consideration of the concepts, but which also helped them cross a cognitive threshold in relation to teaching others about their concept. Interestingly, one student actually described their blog as a 'safe' space for carrying out this liminal transition, even though it was open to the world.

2. The use of pre-session lectures online, led to a strong belief that better use was made of the face-to-face sessions. Students have also remarked that these were positive not only due to the social constructivist nature of the exercises, but that these were supported by a physically flexible learning space which allowed them to stamp their own preferences on the use of the space.

As such, very much preliminary consideration of the rich seam of data collected suggests that the blended approach has helped to transform the nature and benefits of the course thus far.

Liminality

The student teachers with whom I'm working are presently developing some blogs which are intended to help them think about the meaning of core geographical concepts (e.g. space, place, globalisation) which are the central point of the new Key Stage 3 curriculum (for 11-14 year olds) for Geogrpahy in England. The intention is to give them some 'space' in which they can build a series of links, create some thoughts and generally 'play' with the ideas in a relatively informal, yet public, setting. As expected there are a variety of reactions, but for all there has been a clear willingness to search for interesting and creative material on the web and a belief that the exercise is helping them think more creatively and investigate resource sources that they would otherwise not have considered previously.

Can these perspectives and developments be seen as the creation of 'liminal space'? Liminality is an idea, popularised by Victor Turner (a cultural anthropologist) that focuses on rites and rituals of passage. As the individual passes from one section of society to another, they are at a point on a 'threshold', being neither a member of one or other part of society. This has seemingly been broadened out as a concept to cover the general notion of 'in-betweeness'! The students are developing their blogs, the end result being a twenty minute lesson which they must present to others in the group focusing on their given concept. As such, can the development of the blog and the learning which takes place there be seen as a liminal space? Are they moving through a transitional space from understanding a concept to some degree, to being able to teach other students about it? As such does this constitute liminality?